Chapter 07Part 2: The craft

Positioning models

There is no single way to define what a brand stands for. Strategists have built models for it, each a different lens on the same question.

A woman presents Simon Sinek's Golden Circle with the rings Why, How and What on a whiteboard to colleagues at a table.
A team works with Simon Sinek's Golden Circle.

Why strategists use models

A brand lives in many heads at once, and each of them sees something slightly different. Models help to put it on paper, so that everyone who works on a brand talks about the same thing. All positioning models try to describe a brand in a way that keeps it consistent across every touchpoint. And they all face the same danger: becoming too abstract and too focused on the company's own view. Words such as innovation, quality or partnership appear in countless positioning documents and distinguish no one.

The models differ mainly in where they begin. Some start with a belief, some with the identity of the brand, some with the customer or the product. The following overview shows the most important ones and how they compare.


Starting from a belief: the Golden Circle

Simon Sinek, author of Start with Why, arranges a brand in three rings. On the outside is the what, in the middle the how, and at the core the why, the purpose that only a few organisations can name clearly.1 Successful organisations, Sinek argues, communicate from the inside out. The why delivers the reason to buy, the what delivers the proof.2

The model is easy to grasp, which explains much of its appeal. Its critics point out that it looks at the brand only from the inside and says little about customers or competitors. The Golden Circle describes a belief. Other models go further and describe the full identity of a brand.


Starting from identity: Burmann and Esch

Two German approaches focus on the identity of a brand. Christoph Burmann, marketing professor in Bremen, developed the identity based approach to brand management. It describes a brand through components taken from social science and psychological research on identity.3

It is rooted in the brand's origin, with the brand vision as its counterpart looking ahead. Around these sit the brand's competences, its values and personality, and the performance it delivers to customers.4 Franz-Rudolf Esch, also a marketing professor, refined the Brand Steering Wheel. It divides the identity into four quadrants, rational dimensions on the left and emotional ones on the right, with the brand's core competence at the centre.5 Both models are thorough, and both are strong at describing who a brand is. What they leave open is how that identity connects with the market.


Starting from the customer: the Brand-Market Connector

Annette Bruce and Christoph Jeromin, authors of Agile Markenführung, start from a conviction: no brand can be successful in the long run without a customer focus. The company's and the competitors' perspectives are indispensable, but they only become relevant in relation to the customer.6 At the centre of their Brand-Market Connector is desirability, the question of how the brand creates desire among customers. Alongside it sit differentiation, the position the brand wants to hold against competitors, and deliverability, what the company must be able to do to make the brand attractive and distinct.7

The model is completed by a short list of principles the authors call non-negotiables. They serve as guard rails between top management, which is responsible for the strategy, and the people in direct contact with customers, who carry it out.8 The fewer of these principles there are, the better. Eight to ten are common, and twenty suggest that the strategy is not clear enough.9


Key takeaways

  1. 01

    Positioning models help everyone who works on a brand talk about the same thing.

  2. 02

    They differ mainly in where they begin: with a belief, with identity or with the customer.

  3. 03

    Identity models such as Burmann and Esch describe who a brand is, customer models connect it with the market.


Frequently asked questions

A brand positioning model is a framework that helps companies describe what their brand stands for. It structures questions about purpose, identity, customers and competitors so that everyone working on the brand shares the same picture. Well known examples include the Golden Circle, the Brand Steering Wheel, the Brand-Market Connector, the Brand Holosphere and the Unilever Brand Key.

No model is best for every brand. Identity models describe in depth who a brand is, customer focused models connect the brand with market needs, and comprehensive models try to combine both. Smaller brands often benefit from a simple model, while large organisations with many markets may need a more complete one. The right choice depends on size, market and team.

The Brand Steering Wheel is a German brand identity model refined by marketing professor Franz-Rudolf Esch. It places the brand's core competence at the centre and arranges the identity in four quadrants around it. Rational dimensions sit on the left, emotional dimensions on the right.


Books on this topic

Start with Why Simon Sinek
Agile Markenführung Annette Bruce, Christoph Jeromin

Sources

1. Simon Sinek: Frag immer erst: warum. Wie Top-Firmen und Führungskräfte zum Erfolg inspirieren. München, Redline, 2014, p. 40.

2. Ibid., p. 43.

3. Bernd Radtke: Markenidentitätsmodelle. Analyse von Ansätzen zur Erfassung der Markenidentität. Wiesbaden, Springer Gabler (essentials), 2014, p. 43.

4. Ibid., p. 45.

5. Ibid., p. 46.

6. Annette Bruce, Christoph Jeromin: Agile Markenführung. Wie Sie Ihre Marke stark machen für dynamische Märkte. Wiesbaden, Springer Gabler, 2016, p. 147.

7. Ibid., pp. 147, 156.

8. Ibid., p. 159.

9. Ibid., p. 167.


Keep reading