Chapter 06Part 2: The craft
The art of focus
No brand can be everything to everyone. Positioning means choosing one clear place in people's minds and giving up the rest. How to find that place has been debated for decades.
Why focus is so hard
No brand can be everything to everyone. Yet almost every company is tempted to try, because every offer left out feels like a sale lost. Marty Neumeier, brand strategist and author of The Brand Gap, explains why focus is so difficult. It means giving something up, and that goes against the instinct that a smaller range means smaller profits.
His answer is that it is often better to be number one in a small category than number three in a large one.1 There are no boring products, he adds, only boring brands, and any brand can become charismatic with enough courage and imagination.2 Positioning is the art of this focus. How it is done has been debated for decades, and every decade has added its own answer.
Positioning: the empty slot in the mind
The classic answer comes from Al Ries and Jack Trout, two American advertising strategists who made positioning famous with their book Positioning. In a flood of communication, they argue, only companies that specialise, state their promise clearly and concentrate on certain markets survive.3 The message has to be simplified as far as possible and then trimmed once more. Only then does it reach the customer's memory and stay there.4 To anchor itself, a brand first needs not a message but an empty slot in the mind that no other brand has taken yet.5 Customers arrange brands like rungs on small ladders in their heads, and each brand occupies one rung.6
From this follows a lesson that many leaders get wrong. The strength of a product does not come from the strength of the organisation. It is the other way round: the organisation draws its power from the position its product holds in the minds of customers.7
The evolution of positioning
Positioning is not a fixed rule but an idea that has shifted with every era, from loud product claims to today's experiments. Each decade reframed what it means to stand apart.
-
1950s
The Product era
Brands competed on what the product could do, and claims grew louder. As me-too products multiplied, features alone stopped setting any brand apart.
Takeaway A strong product is not enough when everyone offers the same.
Hamm's positioned itself on the product, as America's most refreshing beer.
-
1960s
The Image era
David Ogilvy argued that the image of a brand outlasts any single product claim. The work moved toward reputation, character and trust.
Takeaway Brands need credibility and character, not only benefits.
Ogilvy built brands on personality and reputation rather than feature lists.
-
1980s
The Positioning era
Al Ries and Jack Trout framed positioning as owning a clear place in the customer's mind, defined against competitors.
Takeaway Without a position, a brand has no relevance.
Miller Lite claimed the light beer territory and made the category its own.
Positioning › -
2010s
The Why era
Simon Sinek's Golden Circle moved the conversation from what a brand sells to why it exists, with purpose winning both customers and talent.
Takeaway People buy why you do it, not only what you do.
Start with Why reframed positioning around purpose and belief.
Golden Circle › -
2020s
The Saturation era
In saturated markets brands win in two opposite ways. Some de-position rivals by solving the customer's most important problem better than anyone, making the competition irrelevant. Others win on sheer distinctiveness, with identities that refuse to look like the category.
Takeaway Out-solve the competition, or out-stand it. Substance or distinctiveness, not sameness.
Zoom out-solved Skype on ease and reliability, while Liquid Death sold plain water as a heavy-metal rebellion.
De-Positioning ›
Axes instead of gaps
An empty slot is not the only way to think about position. Seth Godin, one of the most widely read marketing authors of our time, offers a simple tool: positioning along two axes. The magic, Godin writes, lies in showing that every option can be the right one, depending on what someone wants. Rename the axes, for example to comfort, cost, environmental impact or scalability, and the map looks completely different.8 Possible axes include speed, price, visibility, performance, privacy, sustainability, safety and many more.9
Drawing on the author Bernadette Jiwa, Godin also warns against simply wanting to fill a gap in the market. Anyone who does that is always looking in the rear view mirror. The alternative is to find your own story and the change you want to make. A brand that knows what it stands for does not have to compete.10
How far a name can stretch
Positioning also decides how many brands a company needs. Extending a successful name to more and more products seems perfectly logical: lower costs, easier acceptance, more sales.11 Ries and Trout see it differently.
The typical pattern is success, then extension, then disappointment. A name is like a rubber band. It stretches, but only up to a point, and the further it is stretched, the weaker it becomes.12 They speak of a trap rather than a mistake, because the logic of extension looks so convincing.13
Procter and Gamble is their counterexample. Instead of one umbrella brand, the company positions each product in its own niche, and in their account it earns far more with fewer brands than its rival with more.14 Focus, in other words, applies not only to messages but to entire brand portfolios.
Key takeaways
-
01
Focus means giving something up, and that is why it is so hard.
-
02
Ries and Trout see positioning as taking an empty slot in the customer's mind.
-
03
Godin suggests thinking in axes instead of gaps, while Ries and Trout warn that stretching a name too far weakens it.
Frequently asked questions
The idea of positioning was made famous by the American advertising strategists Al Ries and Jack Trout. They argued that in a world flooded with communication, a brand has to occupy an empty slot in the customer's mind. Their thinking shaped marketing for decades and is still the starting point for most debates about positioning today.
De-Positioning is a strategy by brand strategist Todd Irwin. He argues that the empty slots in customers' minds are already taken. Instead of looking for gaps, brands should create their own space by solving the customer's most important problem better than anyone else, and by building everything around one clear idea. It is an attitude rather than a model to fill in.
Extending a successful brand name to new products looks efficient, because the name is already known. But a name works like a rubber band. The further it is stretched across different products, the weaker its meaning becomes. Positioning experts therefore warn that extension often starts with success and ends in disappointment, especially in crowded markets.
Books on this topic
Sources
1. Marty Neumeier: The Brand Gap. Wie sich die Lücke zwischen Design und Unternehmensstrategie schließen lässt. Pearson, 2022, p. 37.
2. Neumeier 2022.
3. Al Ries, Jack Trout: Positioning. Wie Marken und Unternehmen in übersättigten Märkten überleben. München, Vahlen, 2012, p. 16.
4. Ibid., p. 18.
5. Ibid., p. 33.
6. Ibid., p. 66.
7. Ibid., p. 65.
8. Seth Godin: Das ist Marketing! So wird man wirklich sichtbar. München, Redline, 2019.
9. Ibid., p. 74.
10. Ibid., p. 88.
11. Ries, Trout 2012, p. 127.
12. Ibid., p. 153.
13. Ibid., p. 154.
14. Ibid., p. 123.